返回提示词目录第 1337 页

学术论文批判性评析与作业反馈

依据课程要求和论文原文,评估研究方法与结论,生成评析提纲、草稿或修改反馈。

完整提示词

<context>
The article critique is a staple assignment in health, social science and science degrees, and it is usually marked down for the same reasons: too much summary and too little evaluation, criticism that is generic ("the sample was small") rather than tied to consequences ("with 24 participants the study could only detect large effects, so the null result on anxiety is inconclusive"), strengths ignored, no use of a recognised appraisal framework when the brief expects one (for example CASP for qualitative studies), and no wider literature to judge the paper's contribution. A good critique takes a position on how far the paper's conclusions follow from its methods and results, balances strengths and weaknesses, and follows the brief's structure and word count exactly. Many courses restrict AI-written text; the student is responsible for checking their course policy, and outline or feedback modes keep the writing the student's own.
</context>

<task>
Help with a critique of this article in "{{mode}}" mode.
{{#discipline}}Course: {{discipline}}{{/discipline}}
<brief>
{{brief}}
</brief>
<article>
{{article}}
</article>
{{#my_draft}}
<my_draft>
{{my_draft}}
</my_draft>
{{/my_draft}}

1. Read the brief and list its required sections, word limit, criteria and any named appraisal framework. Follow them over the default structure below.
2. Summarise the article in about 100 words: aim, design, sample, main findings, authors' conclusion.
3. Plan the critique section by section: the research question and rationale; design and whether it fits the question; sampling and recruitment; measures or data collection; analysis; ethics; results and how they are presented; whether the discussion's conclusions follow; contribution to the field. For each, note one or two specific strengths or weaknesses, the evidence in the article (with page or section), and what it means for trusting the conclusions.
4. Name the appraisal framework that fits the design if the brief does not, and use its questions to make sure nothing important is missed.
5. Mode outline: give the plan as a paragraph-by-paragraph outline with word budgets and topic sentences to write in the student's own words. Mode full-draft: write the critique to the word count in an academic register, with [cite: …] markers where the student must add wider literature. Mode feedback-on-my-draft: mark the student's draft against the brief and criteria, quoting their sentences, and give the five changes that would raise the mark most.
6. End with a checklist against the brief.
</task>

<constraints>
- Use only the article text given; quote or point to sections for every strength and weakness. Never invent page numbers; use section names if pages are not shown.
- Every criticism must state its consequence for the findings. No generic criticism without a reason.
- Do not invent sources for the wider literature. Use [cite: what kind of source is needed] markers instead.
- If the article text is missing or only an abstract, say a critique is not possible yet and ask for the full text.
- Keep to the brief's word limit, structure and citation style. If the brief and these steps disagree, the brief wins.
- Remind the student once to check their course's rules on AI use and to write the final text in their own words where required.
</constraints>

<output_format>
## The article in brief
About 100 words.
## Critique plan
Table: section | strength or weakness | evidence in the article | what it means.
## Draft or feedback
The outline, the full draft, or the feedback, depending on mode.
## Check before submitting
Checklist against the brief.
</output_format>

可替换内容

  • {{mode}}
  • {{#discipline}}
  • {{discipline}}
  • {{/discipline}}
  • {{brief}}
  • {{article}}
  • {{#my_draft}}
  • {{my_draft}}
  • {{/my_draft}}
  • [cite: …]
  • [cite: what kind of source is needed]

分类与标签

学习教育、论文评析、课程作业、学术写作、草稿反馈

前往 AI 图片创作