构建面向预算决策者的商业论证
用买方提供的数据核算项目价值、成本与回本周期,呈现保守和预期情境,并整理风险及内部决策摘要。
完整提示词
<context>
You help a B2B seller, consultant or agency build the business case their champion will present internally to the person who controls the budget. The champion will be asked hard questions when the seller is not in the room, so the case must be in the buyer's language and stand on the buyer's own numbers. Business cases fail when they use the vendor's marketing statistics, count the same saving twice, ignore the buyer's internal costs (staff time, migration, training), present one optimistic number instead of a range, and never say what happens if the project slips. A credible case is conservative by default, shows every assumption, and leaves the finance reviewer nothing to unpick.
</context>
<task>
<discovery_notes>
{{discovery_notes}}
</discovery_notes>
<pricing>
{{pricing}}
</pricing>
{{#buyer_figures}}<buyer_figures>
{{buyer_figures}}
</buyer_figures>{{/buyer_figures}}
1. List the gaps: every figure the case needs that the buyer has not given. Mark each [X] and write the question the seller should ask the champion to fill it.
2. Cost of the problem today: per value driver (time saved, cost avoided, revenue gained, risk reduced), the formula and the result from the buyer's figures, labelled "stated" or "assumption". Annualise.
3. Value model: a conservative case (lower bound inputs, adoption ramp: for example 50% of the benefit in the first year) and an expected case. No best case unless asked. Avoid double counting: one saving per hour or unit.
4. Costs: the seller's price plus the buyer's internal costs (implementation hours, training, running costs). Total cost over the contract term.
5. Payback in months and net value over the term for both cases; show the arithmetic.
6. Risks: adoption, implementation delay, data or integration, dependency on key people, and the cost of doing nothing or waiting six months. Give a mitigation for each.
7. One-page summary for the budget holder, written as the champion would present it: the problem in one sentence, the recommendation, the numbers, the risks, the decision needed and by when.
</task>
<constraints>
- Use only the buyer's and seller's figures. Never invent benchmarks, industry averages or customer results. If the seller wants to cite another customer's result, mark it [verify and get permission].
- Show every formula; totals must add up.
- Write the summary in the buyer's terms (their goals, their metrics), not product features.
- No exaggeration: if the conservative case does not pay back within the term, say so plainly and suggest what would change that (smaller scope, phasing, a different value driver).
- If the problem or the price is missing, ask for it and stop.
</constraints>
<output_format>
## Gaps to close
Table: Missing figure | Why it matters | Question for the champion.
## Cost of the problem
Table: Value driver | Formula | Annual amount | Source (stated or assumption).
## Value model
Table: Driver | Conservative | Expected, with the adoption assumptions listed below.
## Cost and payback
Table: Cost item | Year 1 | Over term. Then payback months and net value for each case, with arithmetic.
## Risks and mitigations
Table: Risk | Likelihood (low, medium, high) | Mitigation | Owner.
## One-page summary
Under 300 words, headed for the budget holder, ready for the champion to paste into an internal memo.
</output_format>可替换内容
- {{discovery_notes}}
- {{pricing}}
- {{#buyer_figures}}
- {{buyer_figures}}
- {{/buyer_figures}}
- [X]
- [verify and get permission]
分类与标签
商业营销、B2B销售、商业论证、项目回报