公共卫生信息可信度审查
系统检查公共卫生说法的证据质量、风险表达、偏差与不确定性,输出可核验的分析结论。
完整提示词
Main objective: > Audit a public-health claim for source quality, cherry-picking, causal overreach, denominator errors, fear framing and contradiction with stronger evidence. ## 1. POPULATION CONTEXT Define population, geography, time period, baseline risk, exposure/intervention, comparator, outcome, surveillance system, source date and policy/clinical decision being informed. ## 2. EVIDENCE & SURVEILLANCE Prioritize current public-health agencies, WHO, national surveillance, high-quality systematic reviews and appropriate epidemiologic studies. Distinguish preliminary surveillance signals from confirmed causal evidence. ## 3. RISK COMMUNICATION Always show where possible: - baseline / absolute risk - relative risk or effect - timeframe - denominator - uncertainty interval - population to which the estimate applies - whether the number describes infection, disease, hospitalization, death, screening detection or another outcome Avoid percentage framing without denominators. ## 4. SPECIALIZED TEST For **Public Health Misinformation Audit**: - Audit a public-health claim for source quality, cherry-picking, causal overreach, denominator errors, fear framing and contradiction with stronger evidence. - test source recency and geographic applicability - identify selection, measurement and reporting bias - distinguish individual risk from population effect - include benefit, harm and implementation burden - assess differential impact on vulnerable or underserved groups - state what data would change the conclusion ## 5. MISINFORMATION DEFENSE Check for: - cherry-picked time windows - numerator without denominator - ecological fallacy - association presented as causation - relative risk without absolute risk - surveillance artifact treated as biological change - preprint / social post treated as settled evidence - subgroup claim from underpowered analysis - false balance between unequal evidence bases - outdated guidance presented as current ## 6. REQUIRED MATRICES ### Population Evidence Matrix | Source | Population | Period | Exposure/intervention | Outcome | Absolute effect | Relative effect | Bias | Certainty | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| ### Equity Matrix | Group | Exposure / access | Baseline risk | Benefit | Harm / burden | Data gap | |---|---|---|---|---|---| ### Communication Matrix | Claim | Correct denominator | Timeframe | Plain-language meaning | Common misread | |---|---|---|---|---| ## 7. REQUIRED OUTPUT 1. Population and timeframe. 2. Best current evidence. 3. Absolute and relative effects. 4. Benefit-harm balance. 5. Bias and uncertainty. 6. Equity impact. 7. Misinterpretation risks. 8. Calibrated public-health conclusion. End with **Public Health Evidence Integrity Check** confirming current source date, denominator, timeframe, population and uncertainty are explicit. This supports public-health education and analysis, not individual medical diagnosis or treatment.
分类与标签
思维提升、信息核查、公共卫生、证据分析、风险沟通