学生贷款还款方案比较
帮你比较不同学贷制度下的月供、总还款与提前还款取舍,并列出需向官方核实的规则。
完整提示词
<context>
Student loans behave very differently by country, and the right question depends on the system. In **income-contingent** systems (for example the UK, Australia and New Zealand), repayments are a percentage of income above a threshold and any balance left after a set period is written off, so many borrowers never repay in full and overpaying can be money thrown away. In **amortising** systems with options (for example US federal loans), the borrower chooses between fixed payment plans and income-driven plans, with forgiveness after a number of years under some plans and public-service routes; private loans have fewer protections. The rules change often, so every threshold, rate and forgiveness term must be checked on the official source.
Country: {{country}}
Income: {{income}}
<loans>
{{loans}}
</loans>
</context>
<task>
1. How your loan system works: classify the loans as income-contingent, amortising with plan choices, or private, and explain the mechanics in plain words for this country. State thresholds, repayment percentages and write-off periods only where you are confident, labelled "check the current figure"; otherwise ask the person to supply them from their statement.
2. Your loans: table each loan with balance, rate, type and current payment.
3. Options compared, with their numbers:
- Income-contingent: annual and monthly repayment = rate x (income - threshold); project whether the balance would be repaid before write-off under their expected income path (state the income growth and interest assumptions), and estimate total repaid.
- Amortising: monthly payment for the standard term (show the formula), alternative plans available (extended, graduated, income-driven) with the payment and total paid for each, and any forgiveness timing and whether forgiven amounts may be taxable.
- Private: the fixed schedule, and the trade-off of refinancing (lower rate versus losing government protections such as income-driven plans, deferment or forgiveness).
4. Should you overpay: give the decision logic for their system. For income-contingent loans, show the scenario where overpaying saves money (likely to repay in full anyway) versus where it does not (likely write-off). For amortising loans, compare the loan rate with other uses: employer pension match, high-interest debt, emergency fund. Present it as trade-offs, not an instruction.
5. Rules to verify: a list of the specific figures and rules the person must confirm on the official website or with their servicer.
6. Questions for your loan servicer.
</task>
<constraints>
{{> guardrails/professional-limits}}
- Do not tell the person to stop paying, default, or ignore letters. If they are struggling, explain hardship options such as income-driven plans, deferment or forbearance where they exist, and their costs.
- Label every assumption (income growth, inflation, interest rate path). Projections over decades are rough; give ranges.
- Do not recommend lenders or refinancing companies.
- If the plan type is unclear, ask for the statement details that identify it before projecting.
{{> output/uncertainty}}
</constraints>
<output_format>
## How your loan system works
Short paragraphs.
## Your loans
Table.
## Options compared
Table: option | monthly payment now | years to clear or write-off | total paid | forgiven or written off | notes. Then the formulas.
## Should you overpay
Decision logic with their numbers.
## Rules to verify
Checklist.
## Questions for your loan servicer
Numbered.
</output_format>可替换内容
- {{country}}
- {{income}}
- {{loans}}
- {{> guardrails/professional-limits}}
- {{> output/uncertainty}}
分类与标签
财务理财、学生贷款、月供测算、提前还款、债务减免