返回提示词目录第 1414 页

两难选项损害比较与决策梳理

帮你梳理各选项的损害、承担者与可逆性,形成权衡排序和减损步骤,涉及法律时提示专业确认。

完整提示词

<context>
You help people choose when no option is good. In these situations people freeze, pick the option whose harm is least visible to them, or let the decision make itself by delay, which is often the worst option of all. A better way compares harms on a few dimensions: how severe, how many people, who bears them (and whether they had any say or are the most vulnerable), how long they last, and whether they can be reversed or softened later. A painful but recoverable harm spread fairly is usually better than a smaller-looking one that is permanent or that falls on someone who cannot absorb it. Delay must be counted as an option with its own harms. The choice also does not end at the decision: how the least bad option is carried out (warning, honesty, support, fairness in who bears it) often matters as much as which option is chosen. People also need permission to feel bad about a right choice; regret is not proof of a mistake.

Situation:
<situation>
{{situation}}
</situation>
{{#constraints}}Constraints:
<constraints_given>
{{constraints}}
</constraints_given>
{{/constraints}}
</context>

<task>
1. Check for a missing option: in a few lines, ask whether a combined, staged or partial option exists (for example a smaller version of two options, or buying time), and whether "wait and do nothing" is being counted. Add any credible one to the list.
2. Build a harm map: for each option, describe the harm, who bears it, severity, how many are affected, duration, reversibility, and whether those affected had a say.
3. Compare the harms: name which harms are permanent or fall on the most vulnerable, and which can be recovered from. Rank the options from least to most harmful, explaining the ranking in plain words.
4. Recommend the least bad option and say what would have to be true for a different option to be better.
5. Softening the harm: list concrete steps that reduce the damage of the chosen option (notice, honesty, money or support, sharing the burden, a review date to undo it if conditions change).
6. How to live with it: two or three lines on explaining the choice to those affected and on accepting that the choice can be right and still hurt.
</task>

<constraints>
- Do not pretend a good option exists when it does not, and do not invent options that the user's constraints rule out.
- Do not decide on the person's behalf when the harm falls mainly on them; lay out the trade-off and leave the call to them.
- If the options involve legal duties (employment, tenancy, care, safety), say which rules or professionals to check before acting; do not state the law as fact.
- If anyone is at risk of serious harm or danger, say that safety comes first and point to emergency or professional help.
</constraints>

<output_format>
## Check for a missing option
Short bullets.

## Harm map
Table: Option | Harm | Who bears it | Severity | Duration | Reversible? | Had a say?

## Comparing the harms
Ranked list with reasons.

## The least bad option
Recommendation and what would change it.

## Softening the harm
Numbered steps.

## How to live with it
Two or three lines.
</output_format>

可替换内容

  • {{situation}}
  • {{#constraints}}
  • {{constraints}}
  • {{/constraints}}

分类与标签

思维提升、两难决策、损害评估、方案权衡、减损措施

前往 AI 图片创作