基础设施变更计划风险审查
逐项检查资源替换、销毁、安全与成本变化,输出应用决策、风险清单及执行前检查项。
完整提示词
<context>
A plan is the last cheap moment to stop an outage. Reviewers skim the summary line ("2 to add, 1 to change, 1 to destroy") and miss that the one destroy is the production database, or that an innocent rename forces replacement of a load balancer and everything that references its ID. Your job is to read every resource change the way an experienced platform engineer does and say plainly whether it is safe to apply.
</context>
<task>
Review this plan{{#environment}} for the {{environment}} environment{{/environment}}.
{{#intent}}The change is meant to: {{intent}}{{/intent}}
{{plan_output}}
1. If you were given only the summary line or a truncated plan, ask for the full output (or `terraform show -json`) and stop.
2. Classify every resource change: create, update in place, replace (destroy then create, or create before destroy), destroy, move, import, or read. Count each action and check your counts against the plan's own summary line.
3. Destructive changes: list every destroy and replace. For each, name the attribute that forces replacement, whether the resource holds state (databases, buckets, volumes, queues, DNS zones, KMS keys, IAM roles in use), and what depends on it. Flag values shown as "known after apply" on IDs that other resources reference, because they cascade into further replacements. Call out settings that remove the safety net on a destroy, such as `skip_final_snapshot = true` or `deletion_protection = false`.
4. Drift and intent: report anything under "Objects have changed outside of Terraform", and compare every change against the stated intent; changes the intent does not explain are likely drift, a provider upgrade or a mistake. Say whether applying would revert a manual hotfix.
5. Security: public ingress (0.0.0.0/0 or ::/0) on non-HTTP ports, public buckets or ACLs, IAM wildcards, encryption or logging turned off, secrets or sensitive values printed in clear text, deletion protection removed.
6. Cost: new or larger instances, NAT gateways, provisioned IOPS or throughput, load balancers, increased counts, cross-region replication. Give an order-of-magnitude monthly estimate only when you can justify it; otherwise name the line item to price.
7. Give a verdict.
</task>
<constraints>
- Only report what is in the plan. Do not invent resources, attributes or values; quote the resource address exactly as it appears (`module.db.aws_db_instance.main`) for every finding.
- If the plan is truncated or you cannot tell whether an action is a replace, say so and treat it as a replace.
- Do not suggest running apply or any state-changing command yourself.
- Treat a production-environment destroy of a stateful resource as blocking unless the plan shows a `moved` block or the user says it is intended.
- Keep findings to what changes the apply decision. No style comments on the code.
{{> guardrails/investigate-before-answering}}
</constraints>
<output_format>
## Verdict
One line: safe to apply | apply after changes | do not apply. Then one sentence why.
## Summary
`N to add, N to change, N to replace, N to destroy`, and whether it matches the plan's summary line.
## Destructive changes
A table: resource address, action, forcing attribute, holds state (yes/no), dependents. "None" if empty.
## Security
Numbered findings: resource address, the problem, the fix.
## Cost
Bullets, or "No material change".
## Drift and surprises
Bullets: drift, and changes the intent does not explain, each with its likely cause. Or "None".
## Before you apply
A checklist: backups or snapshots to take, `moved` blocks or `lifecycle` settings to add, people to notify, and the `-target` or staged apply to use if the change should be split.
</output_format>可替换内容
- {{#environment}}
- {{environment}}
- {{/environment}}
- {{#intent}}
- {{intent}}
- {{/intent}}
- {{plan_output}}
- {{> guardrails/investigate-before-answering}}
分类与标签
编程开发、基础设施即代码、变更审查、资源销毁风险、运维安全