返回提示词目录第 1411 页

起草陪审团指示与裁决问题

根据给定范本与法律依据拟写中立指示和裁决问题,标注修改与异议风险供律师审核。

完整提示词

<context>
Jury instructions decide what the jury is allowed to find, and errors in them are a common ground of appeal. Courts prefer the jurisdiction's pattern instructions and are wary of argumentative departures from them, so the skill lies in choosing the right patterns, filling the bracketed options correctly, adding a tailored instruction only where a pattern does not fit and an authority supports it, keeping the language neutral, and making sure the verdict form asks the questions the instructions set up. A party that wants an instruction usually must request it in writing with its authority and object on the record to its refusal, so each proposed instruction needs a numbered source note.

Court and side: {{court}}

Claims and defences:
<claims>
{{claims}}
</claims>

Pattern instructions and authorities supplied:
<pattern_instructions>
{{pattern_instructions}}
</pattern_instructions>
</context>

<task>
1. Instruction list: the instructions this case needs, in the usual order (preliminary and general, burden and standard of proof, each claim's elements, each defence, damages or sentencing-related matters where the jury decides them, deliberation), saying for each whether a supplied pattern covers it.
2. Draft each proposed instruction, numbered, in plain neutral language, using the pattern text where supplied, filling its options for this case, and marking every change from the pattern.
3. After each instruction, a source note: the pattern number or authority it rests on, and for any tailored language, why it is needed.
4. Verdict form outline: the questions the jury answers, in an order that matches the instructions, including special interrogatories if the claims call for them.
5. Objection risks: instructions or wording the other side is likely to oppose, and the strongest version of their objection.
6. Gaps to research: elements or defences for which no pattern or authority was supplied.
</task>

<constraints>
{{> guardrails/professional-limits}}
- Draft only from the patterns and authorities supplied. Never quote a pattern instruction or case from memory; where one is needed and not supplied, write [PATTERN NEEDED] or [AUTHORITY NEEDED].
- Keep instructions neutral; do not argue the facts or comment on the evidence. If the input asks for an argumentative or improper instruction, leave it out and explain why under Objection risks.
- Mark every departure from the pattern text clearly so the attorney can defend it.
- This is a draft for attorney review before filing.
{{> output/uncertainty}}
</constraints>

<output_format>
## Instruction list
Table: No. | Topic | Pattern supplied? | Notes.
## Proposed instructions
Each numbered instruction, then "Source:" and "Changes from pattern:".
## Verdict form outline
Numbered questions.
## Objection risks
Bullets.
## Gaps to research
Bullets.
</output_format>

可替换内容

  • {{court}}
  • {{claims}}
  • {{pattern_instructions}}
  • {{> guardrails/professional-limits}}
  • {{> output/uncertainty}}
  • [PATTERN NEEDED]
  • [AUTHORITY NEEDED]

分类与标签

办公效率、诉讼文书、陪审团指示、裁决表、律师审核

前往 AI 图片创作