收入确认流程与证据链审计
沿合同、履约、开票和账务记录梳理收入确认依据,标记期间、金额及控制环节的待核实问题。
完整提示词
I want a deep audit of the revenue recognition process and the evidence chain from contract/order to invoice, delivery/performance obligation, journal and financial statement. Main objective: > Determine whether revenue arises in the right amount, period and entity according to the actual contractual/economic event and the applicable accounting framework. This is not: - legal advice - automatically applying IFRS 15/ASC 606 without establishing the framework - only an invoice-to-GL reconciliation - an assumption that invoicing date = revenue recognition date ## 1. ACCOUNTING FRAMEWORK Always establish: - IFRS - US GAAP - local GAAP - other If unknown: **ACCOUNTING FRAMEWORK: NOT VERIFIED** ## 2. REVENUE STREAMS For each: ```text Revenue stream: Contract type: Customer: Performance obligation: Billing timing: Recognition timing: Variable consideration: Refund/return: ``` ## 3. CONTRACT ## 4. ORDER ## 5. PERFORMANCE OBLIGATION ## 6. DELIVERY ## 7. ACCEPTANCE ## 8. SERVICE PERIOD ## 9. SUBSCRIPTION ## 10. USAGE ## 11. MILESTONE ## 12. LICENSE ## 13. PROFESSIONAL SERVICES ## 14. BUNDLE ## 15. DISCOUNT ## 16. ALLOCATION ## 17. VARIABLE CONSIDERATION ## 18. BONUS ## 19. PENALTY ## 20. REFUND ## 21. RETURN ## 22. CANCELLATION ## 23. CREDIT NOTE ## 24. DEFERRED REVENUE ## 25. CONTRACT ASSET ## 26. CONTRACT LIABILITY ## 27. UNBILLED REVENUE ## 28. BILLING IN ADVANCE ## 29. BILLING IN ARREARS ## 30. CUT-OFF Critical. ## 31. PERIOD-END SHIPMENT ## 32. CUSTOMER ACCEPTANCE ## 33. BILL-AND-HOLD Only if relevant. ## 34. CONSIGNMENT ## 35. PRINCIPAL VS AGENT ## 36. GROSS VS NET ## 37. MARKETPLACE ## 38. COMMISSION ## 39. PAYMENT PROCESSOR ## 40. MULTI-CURRENCY ## 41. FX ## 42. TAX Tax is usually not revenue where pass-through, depending on the framework. ## 43. RELATED PARTY ## 44. INTERCOMPANY ## 45. MANUAL JOURNAL ## 46. SYSTEM AUTOMATION ## 47. RECONCILIATION Contract/order -> invoice -> subledger -> GL. ## 48. REFUND RESERVE ## 49. BAD DEBT Distinguish from revenue recognition. ## 50. CHURN ## 51. CONTRACT MODIFICATION ## 52. UPGRADE ## 53. DOWNGRADE ## 54. RENEWAL ## 55. FREE TRIAL ## 56. PROMOTIONAL CREDIT ## 57. GIFT CARD/CREDIT ## 58. LOYALTY ## 59. DATA QUALITY ## 60. FALSE POSITIVE RULES Invoice before recognition is not automatically wrong. Revenue before cash is not automatically wrong. Deferred revenue is not a problem by itself. ## 61. EVIDENCE TIERS ```text A - contract/delivery/ledger evidence proves recognition treatment B - complete system transaction path C - strong accounting pattern evidence D - treatment requires contractual/framework verification E - control hardening ``` ## 62. STATUS ```text CONFIRMED LIKELY NOT VERIFIED CONTROLLED NOT APPLICABLE ``` ## 63. SEVERITY P0: - systemic material revenue misstatement P1: - repeatable material cut-off/recognition error P2: - material control/contract-treatment gap P3: - limited revenue-process issue P4: - hardening ## 64. FINDING FORMAT ```text ID: Severity: Status: Evidence tier: Revenue stream: Contract: Performance obligation: Billing: Recognition: Period: Expected accounting: Actual accounting: Amount/materiality: Evidence: Framework basis: Remediation: Regression/control: ``` ## 65. REVENUE MATRIX | Stream | Billing | Recognition | Deferred/unbilled | Control | |---|---|---|---|---| ## 66. SECOND PASS Test: - period-end transactions - refunds - cancellations - bundles - modifications - advance billing - principal/agent - customer acceptance - manual adjustments ## 67. FINAL QUALITY GATE Confirm: - framework - streams - contracts - obligations - timing - amount - variable consideration - cut-off - deferred/unbilled - refunds - gross/net - reconciliation ## 68. OUTPUT `REVENUE_RECOGNITION_AUDIT.md` # FINAL RULE Revenue is the accounting result of a satisfied economic obligation under the applicable framework, not just the moment an invoice was created or cash was received.
分类与标签
财务理财、收入确认审计、财务报告、会计控制、期末截止测试