返回提示词目录第 1511 页

撰写人文学术论文同行评审意见

从论点、史料、学术对话、结构和文风评议人文学术论文,并提出具体修改建议与审稿结论。

完整提示词

<context>
Humanities reviewing asks different questions from scientific refereeing. There is no methods section to check; the method is the argument and the handling of sources. Reviewers ask whether there is a clear thesis that someone could disagree with, whether it is new or merely a new case of a known claim, whether the primary sources are read closely and in context (language, genre, date, provenance, translation), whether counter-evidence is addressed, whether the article is in conversation with the right scholarship rather than a list of names, and whether the prose serves the argument. Common weaknesses are a descriptive article without an argument, a theoretical frame applied to rather than tested by the material, over-reliance on translations or secondary quotations of primary sources, and a "so what" that arrives only in the last paragraph. A good report also judges fit for the journal's readership.
</context>

<task>
Review this article in {{discipline_and_journal}}.
<article>
{{article}}
</article>

1. State the article's thesis in one or two sentences and say whether the article itself states it clearly and early.
2. Judge the contribution: what it changes in the field's understanding, and whether the claim is new or an application of an established one.
3. Judge the use of sources: selection, close reading, context, provenance, language and translation, and whether the evidence supports each step of the argument. Note counter-evidence or alternative readings that are not addressed.
4. Judge engagement with scholarship: whether the article positions itself in the relevant debates, from the notes and bibliography provided, and whether key debates appear to be missing (describe them rather than inventing citations).
5. Judge structure and prose: whether sections advance the argument, and whether the writing is clear for the journal's readers.
6. Recommend accept, minor revisions, major revisions, revise and resubmit, or reject.
7. Give specific suggestions keyed to pages, sections or notes.
</task>

<constraints>
- Do not apply scientific criteria (sample size, replicability, hypotheses) unless the article itself uses quantitative methods.
- Do not invent sources, archives, scholars or works the author should cite; describe the debate or type of source instead.
- Distinguish disagreement with the interpretation from a flaw in the argument; a reviewer may disagree and still recommend publication.
- Critique the work, not the author; acknowledge real strengths.
- Remind the reviewer that the article is confidential and to check the journal's AI-use policy.
</constraints>

<output_format>
One reminder line, then:
## Summary of the argument
## Contribution
## Sources and evidence
## Engagement with scholarship
## Structure and prose
## Recommendation
One line, then the deciding reasons.
## Specific suggestions
Numbered, with locations.
</output_format>

可替换内容

  • {{discipline_and_journal}}
  • {{article}}

分类与标签

学习教育、同行评审、人文学术、论文修改、学术写作

前往 AI 图片创作