面向人工智能时代的作业重设计
围绕原有学习目标改写作业,配套过程检查、口头答辩、人工智能使用规则与评分标准。
完整提示词
<context>
No take-home assignment is AI-proof, and AI-text detectors are unreliable enough that they should not be the basis for accusing a student. What works is design: assess the process as well as the product, tie the work to things a general model does not know (local data, class discussions, the student's own experience or fieldwork), make thinking visible at checkpoints, and include a short oral or in-class component where students explain and extend their work. Equally important is clarity: students need to know exactly which uses of AI are allowed, how to disclose them, and why the rules serve their learning.
</context>
<task>
Redesign this assignment with the AI stance **{{ai_stance}}**.
<current_assignment>
{{current_assignment}}
</current_assignment>
<learning_goals>
{{learning_goals}}
</learning_goals>
1. **Diagnosis:** say which parts of the current assignment a general AI tool could produce convincingly with little student thinking, and which learning goals the current design therefore cannot evidence.
2. **Redesigned assignment:** rewrite the student-facing brief. Keep the learning goals and roughly the same workload. Use the strategies that fit the goals best, typically several of:
- grounding in specific, local or class-generated material (data the class collected, a local issue, an in-class discussion, a text annotated in class);
- personal connection or reflection that is part of the learning, not decoration;
- visible process: proposals, notes, drafts, version history or annotated decisions;
- in-class components under normal conditions for the part that most needs to be the student's own;
- a product that requires judgement about sources or outputs, not just generation.
3. **Process checkpoints:** 3 to 5 dated checkpoints with what students submit and the quick feedback they get.
4. **Oral check:** a 3 to 5 minute conversation or mini-viva protocol with 5 or 6 questions that ask students to explain choices, extend to a new case, or fix a deliberately introduced flaw, with what a secure answer sounds like.
5. **AI-use policy for students** fitted to the stance:
- banned: what counts as AI use, why it is excluded for this task, and which tools remain fine (spell check, for example);
- allowed-with-disclosure: permitted uses (brainstorming, feedback on a draft, explaining a concept) and not permitted uses (generating the submitted text or answers), plus the disclosure rule;
- required: the specific AI task students do, how they evaluate and correct the output, and what they submit to show their judgement (prompts, outputs, critique).
6. **Disclosure statement:** a short template students complete describing any AI use (tool, purpose, what they changed).
7. **Marking changes:** how the rubric shifts weight toward process, reasoning and the oral check, with criteria wording.
8. **Teacher notes:** what to do if you suspect misuse (talk to the student about the work and process first; follow school policy; do not rely on detector scores alone) and equity notes (access to tools at home, students with accommodations).
</task>
<constraints>
- Never claim the design makes AI use impossible or detectable. Say how it makes learning visible instead.
- Do not recommend AI-detection software as evidence of misconduct.
- Keep total student workload close to the original; if the redesign adds time, take something out and say what.
- Do not require students to share private or sensitive personal information; personal-connection tasks must have an alternative.
- If allowed or required AI use needs tools the school has not approved, or students below a tool's minimum age, flag it.
- If the learning goals are unclear, infer them from the assignment, mark them "inferred", and proceed.
</constraints>
<output_format>
## Diagnosis
Bullets: vulnerable parts → goals not evidenced.
## Redesigned assignment
The new student-facing brief.
## Process checkpoints
Table: Checkpoint | Due | Students submit | Feedback.
## Oral check
Protocol, questions, what a secure answer sounds like.
## AI-use policy for students
Student-facing, under about 200 words.
## Disclosure statement
Template.
## Marking changes
Criteria and weights.
## Teacher notes
Bullets.
</output_format>可替换内容
- {{ai_stance}}
- {{current_assignment}}
- {{learning_goals}}
分类与标签
学习教育、作业设计、过程评价、口头答辩、人工智能使用规范