返回提示词目录第 1455 页

撰写基金申请评审回复

将评审意见归纳为主题并对应已做修改,起草带位置说明的回复,同时列出尚未解决的批评与核查事项。

完整提示词

<context>
A resubmission is read by a panel that may include new members who never saw the first version. The response section has to work on its own: it shows that the applicants understood the critique, that the application is now stronger, and exactly where to find each change. Panels mark down responses that go reviewer by reviewer and repeat every minor point, that grovel or argue, that claim changes the new text does not contain, or that ignore the criticisms that actually drove the score. Strong responses lead with the issues that mattered most, group overlapping criticisms into themes, answer each with a concrete change and its location, and disagree rarely, briefly and with evidence. Funders set their own rules for this section (length, whether to mark changes in the text, what may be included), and those rules change, so the applicant must check the current instructions.
</context>

<task>
Write the response-to-review section for this resubmission{{#funder}} to {{funder}}{{/funder}}, within {{page_limit}} page(s).

<reviews>
{{reviews}}
</reviews>

<changes_made>
{{changes_made}}
</changes_made>

1. Extract every distinct criticism from the reviews. Note who raised it, whether more than one reviewer or the panel discussion raised it, and whether it was named as a major weakness or a reason for the score.
2. Group the criticisms into themes (for example rationale, approach and feasibility, rigour and statistics, team and environment, preliminary data). Rank themes by how much they drove the score.
3. Match each criticism to an item in the changes made. List any criticism with no matching change as a gap. Do not invent a change to fill it.
4. Draft the response:
   - An opening of two or three sentences: thank the reviewers once, name the main improvements, and say how the changes are shown in the text if the funder's instructions allow marking.
   - One short paragraph per theme, in rank order. Start with a neutral paraphrase of the concern (not a long quote), then the change, then its location (aim, section, page or figure).
   - Where the applicants did not make a change, say so plainly and give the evidence: a citation, new data, a feasibility argument or a design reason. Keep the tone factual and never suggest the reviewer misread the application.
   - Mention strengths the reviewers praised only if a change might seem to threaten them.
5. Fit the space: estimate the length (about 500 words per page at typical grant formatting, to be checked against the funder's font and margin rules) and cut minor points into a single closing sentence if needed.
6. Before you answer, check that every change you state appears in the changes made, every location matches, every major criticism is answered or listed as a gap, and the draft fits the page limit.
</task>

<constraints>
- Never state a change, a result or new data that is not in the changes made.
- Do not reveal or guess reviewers' identities, and do not quote critiques at length.
- Avoid flattery, apology and defensiveness; one line of thanks is enough.
- Do not state the funder's formatting rules as fact; tell the applicant to check the current instructions for this scheme.
- If the reviews or changes are too thin to match (for example only a score, or "we revised everything"), ask for the specific critiques or the list of changes and stop.
</constraints>

<output_format>
## Gaps to close first
Criticisms with no matching change, each with a suggested action (change the application, add a sentence of rebuttal with evidence, or accept and explain). "None" if there are none.
## Response to review
The section text, ready to paste, with theme headings in bold if space allows. State the estimated length.
## Criticism to change map
Table: Criticism | Raised by | Theme | Change made | Location.
## Notes for the applicant
Up to five points: funder rules to check, places where the new application should be strengthened to match the response, and any tone risk.
</output_format>

可替换内容

  • {{#funder}}
  • {{funder}}
  • {{/funder}}
  • {{page_limit}}
  • {{reviews}}
  • {{changes_made}}

分类与标签

办公效率、基金申请、评审回复、科研写作

前往 AI 图片创作