撰写期刊叙述性综述文章
基于所给文献撰写含摘要、方法与主题综合的综述稿,权衡证据质量并列出投稿前待补内容。
完整提示词
<context>
Narrative reviews are widely read and widely criticised. Editors reject them for being a list of studies, for an unexplained selection of sources that looks cherry-picked, for no critical judgement of study quality, and for a "future research" section that just says more research is needed. Quality criteria for narrative reviews (for example the SANRA scale) ask for a justified importance of the topic, a stated aim, a described literature search, referencing that supports key statements, scientific reasoning that weighs evidence by its quality, and appropriate presentation of data. A narrative review is not a systematic review and should not pretend to be one, but it must still say how the literature was found and selected. The best ones offer a point of view: an organising framework, a judgement on where the evidence is strong and weak, and a specific research agenda.
</context>
<task>
Write a narrative review article on:
<topic>
{{topic}}
</topic>
{{#journal}}Target journal and limits: {{journal}}{{/journal}}
{{#search_description}}
How the sources were found:
{{search_description}}
{{/search_description}}
<sources>
{{sources}}
</sources>
1. Check the sources against the topic: say if they look too few, too old, or one-sided for a publishable review, and continue only with what they can support, noting the gaps.
2. Write a working title and an abstract to the journal's format (unstructured if not stated, about 250 words).
3. Introduction: why the topic matters now, what earlier reviews covered (only if in the sources), and the review's aim and scope.
4. Methods: a short, honest description of how the literature was found and selected, based on the search description. If none was given, write a placeholder paragraph listing what to report. Never describe the review as systematic.
5. Synthesis: thematic sections organised by idea, each comparing studies, stating design and size where it changes the weight, and explaining disagreements.
6. Discussion and future directions: overall judgement of the evidence, its main weaknesses, implications for practice or policy at the strength the evidence allows, and a specific research agenda (which question, which design, which population).
7. Conclusion: one paragraph.
8. List what must be filled before submission: [cite] markers, missing details, checks against the journal's author guidelines.
</task>
<constraints>
- Cite only the sources provided, in author-year form unless the journal style is given. Mark any statement needing a source not in the list with [cite: what kind of source].
- Never invent studies, numbers or reference details. Copy numbers from the source notes exactly.
- Weigh evidence by design and quality, and say where conclusions rest on weak or few studies.
- Keep within the stated word and reference limits; if none, aim for 3,000 to 5,000 words and say so.
- Remind the author once that journals have policies on AI-assisted writing and that they must check, disclose as required, and take responsibility for every claim.
</constraints>
<output_format>
## Title and abstract
Working title, then the abstract.
## Introduction
Prose.
## Methods
Prose or placeholder.
## Synthesis
### headings per theme, prose.
## Discussion and future directions
Prose, with the research agenda as a short numbered list.
## Conclusion
One paragraph.
## Gaps to fill before submission
Checklist.
</output_format>可替换内容
- {{topic}}
- {{#journal}}
- {{journal}}
- {{/journal}}
- {{#search_description}}
- {{search_description}}
- {{/search_description}}
- {{sources}}
- [cite]
- [cite: what kind of source]
分类与标签
内容创作、叙述性综述、学术写作、文献综合、期刊投稿