返回提示词目录第 1312 页

评估期刊与学术会议可信度

综合出版资质、审稿流程与邀稿信号评估投稿渠道,给出可信度判断和核验清单。

完整提示词

<context>
Predatory journals and conferences take fees without providing real peer review, editing, indexing or archiving, and publishing in one can harm a career and waste good work. Hijacked journals go further by cloning a real journal's name and website. No single list is reliable, so checks combine signals: whether claimed indexing is real (DOAJ, Scopus source list, Web of Science Master Journal List, MEDLINE through the NLM Catalog, noting that being in PubMed Central is not the same as MEDLINE); whether the ISSN is registered; whether claimed memberships (COPE, OASPA) appear on those organisations' own member lists; whether the editorial board are real, relevant scholars who list the role themselves; whether peer review and fees are transparent; whether metrics are genuine (an impact factor comes only from Clarivate's Journal Citation Reports); and the tone and promises of invitations. The Think. Check. Submit. checklist summarises these. Legitimate new or small journals can fail some checks, so the result is a weighed judgement, not a single test.
</context>

<task>
Assess whether this venue is legitimate.
<journal>
{{journal}}
</journal>
{{#invitation}}
<invitation>
{{invitation}}
</invitation>
{{/invitation}}

1. Note what you were given and what is missing (website, ISSN, publisher). If the name is close to a well-known journal, raise the possibility of a hijacked or look-alike journal and say how to find the real journal's official site.
2. Assess each signal from the information given: identity (name, ISSN, publisher, address), claimed indexing and memberships, metrics, editorial board, peer-review description and promised timelines, fees and when they are disclosed, scope (narrow and coherent, or everything from medicine to engineering), archiving and licensing, retraction and correction policy, and for conferences the organiser, venue, past proceedings, and whether the event is repeated under many names. Mark each as concerning, reassuring, or unknown.
3. If an invitation was given, analyse it: flattery, generic greetings, unrelated topic, urgency, promised acceptance or review in days, requests to pay early, and sender address.
4. Give a verdict with a confidence level: likely legitimate, caution (verify before submitting), likely predatory, or cannot tell from the information. Explain which signals drove it.
5. List what to verify and where, in order of how much each check settles.
6. Say what to do if it is predatory or the author has already submitted or paid (withdraw in writing, do not sign copyright transfer, ask for confirmation, contact the institution's library or research office).
</task>

<constraints>
- Do not state that a venue is or is not indexed, a COPE member or on any list from memory; say what to check and where. If you recognise the name, you may say so, labelled as something to confirm.
- Do not call a venue predatory on one signal alone; new and regional journals legitimately lack some markers. Weigh the signals and show the reasoning.
- Avoid relying on any single blacklist or whitelist; explain why lists are a starting point only.
- Be specific and calm; the author may already have submitted.
</constraints>

<output_format>
## Verdict
The verdict, confidence, and the signals behind it in two to four sentences.
## Signals
A table: signal | what you found | concerning, reassuring or unknown.
## Invitation red flags
A list quoting the problem phrases, or "No invitation given".
## What to verify
A numbered checklist: check | where | what a good result looks like.
## If it is predatory
Steps for before and after submission or payment.
</output_format>

可替换内容

  • {{journal}}
  • {{#invitation}}
  • {{invitation}}
  • {{/invitation}}

分类与标签

学习教育、学术投稿、期刊核验、掠夺性出版、会议评估

前往 AI 图片创作