返回提示词目录第 1402 页

核查最大首个唯一等宣称

拆解最高级宣称的比较口径,核对来源与竞争案例,给出证据支持的判断和改写。

完整提示词

<context>
Superlatives are easy to make true by quietly narrowing the terms. "Largest" can mean capacity, area, output, revenue or headcount, and the claimant usually picks the measure where they win. The comparison set gets narrowed by geography ("in Europe"), category ("independent", "family-owned", "in its class"), date ("since records began" when records started recently) or an unstated qualifier ("first to offer it at this price"). "First" claims fail when an earlier example existed but was obscure, and "only" claims fail when a competitor launched later. Records can be beaten, and figures can be self-reported. Advertising regulators in many countries expect objective superlatives to be substantiated and the basis stated; puffery ("the best coffee in town") is a matter of opinion and cannot be fact-checked.
</context>

<task>
Check this claim.
<claim>
{{claim}}
</claim>
{{#context}}Context: {{context}}{{/context}}

1. Decide whether the claim is checkable (an objective superlative) or puffery (an opinion). If puffery, say so and stop after explaining why.
2. Define the claim: the measure, the comparison set (place, category, qualifiers), the period and the data source the claimant relies on. Where the claim is ambiguous, list the readings and check the one a typical audience would take.
3. Find the evidence for the claimant's position and their own stated basis, if any.
4. Search for contenders that beat it on the same measure, on a more natural measure, or earlier in time, and check whether any figures are independently verified or self-reported.
5. Give a verdict and the accurate wording the evidence allows.
</task>

<constraints>
- Cite only sources you opened in this session, with links and dates. Never name a contender, figure or date from memory.
- If you have no web access, say so, give no verdict, and list how to verify it (registers, industry bodies, regulators, record keepers).
- "No earlier example found" supports a "first" claim only as far as you searched; say how far.
- Treat self-reported figures as claims, not facts.
- Do not decide whether the claim breaks advertising rules in a given country; you may say it would need substantiation.
</constraints>

<output_format>
## Verdict
One of: accurate, accurate only with qualifiers, misleading, false, unverifiable, or opinion (not checkable). Then two sentences.
## Defining the claim
Measure, comparison set, period and the claimant's basis.
## Evidence
Bullets with links.
## Contenders
Table: contender | measure | value or date | source | verified or self-reported.
## Accurate wording
The claim rewritten with the qualifiers it needs, or "drop the claim".
</output_format>

可替换内容

  • {{claim}}
  • {{#context}}
  • {{context}}
  • {{/context}}

分类与标签

思维提升、事实核查、最高级宣称、证据检索、批判性思维

前往 AI 图片创作