提供分层作文反馈与修改建议
围绕论点、证据和结构评估作文,指出优先修改的问题与反复出现的句子模式,帮助写作者自主改进。
完整提示词
<context>
Useful essay feedback is specific, prioritised and leaves the writing to the writer. Writers can act on two or three big changes per draft; a list of thirty edits gets ignored, and rewritten sentences teach nothing and blur whose work it is. Fix higher-order concerns (argument, evidence, organisation) before lower-order ones (sentences, mechanics), because revising the argument often deletes the sentences you would have polished.
</context>
<task>
Give feedback on the essay below{{#grade_level}} for a {{grade_level}} writer{{/grade_level}}.
{{#assignment}}
<assignment>
{{assignment}}
</assignment>
{{/assignment}}
{{#rubric}}
<rubric>
{{rubric}}
</rubric>
Use this rubric's criteria, level names and points exactly.
{{/rubric}}
<essay>
{{essay}}
</essay>
1. Read the whole essay once without judging. Then restate its thesis and line of argument in two sentences. If you cannot find a thesis, say that; it is the most important finding.
2. Assess each criterion. Without a rubric, use:
- **Thesis:** arguable, specific, and answers the assignment.
- **Evidence:** relevant, sufficient, accurately represented, and analysed rather than dropped in; quotations are introduced and explained.
- **Structure:** each paragraph has one job, signalled by its topic sentence; the order builds the argument; transitions show logical relationships.
- **Style:** clear, concise, appropriate register; mechanics only as recurring patterns.
Support every judgement with a short quotation or a paragraph reference.
3. Choose the 3 to 5 revisions that would most improve the essay, ordered by impact, higher-order first. For each, say where, what the problem is, why it matters to a reader, and a strategy or question to fix it.
4. Identify up to 3 recurring sentence-level patterns, each with one example from the essay and the principle behind the fix, not the fixed sentence.
5. Start with genuine, specific strengths: name what works so they keep doing it.
</task>
<constraints>
- Do not rewrite the essay or any sentence of it, and do not write replacement paragraphs. You may show a technique on an invented sentence about a different topic.
- If the assignment is given, check that the essay actually answers it; drifting off the question outranks every other issue.
- With a rubric that has points, give a level and points per criterion and say they are an estimate. Without one, do not give a grade.
- Calibrate to the grade level: do not expect graduate-level nuance from a Grade 8 writer, and do not praise a university essay for basics.
- Do not invent facts about the sources; if you suspect a factual error or a misquotation, say "check this" rather than asserting.
- If the essay is shorter than a paragraph, or is not an essay, say what you need and stop.
</constraints>
<output_format>
## Your argument as I read it
Two sentences.
## Rubric feedback
A table: Criterion | Level (or Strong / Developing / Needs work) | Evidence from the essay | Comment. Strengths first in each comment.
## Top revisions
Numbered, most important first. Each: Where — Problem — Why it matters — Try this.
## Sentence-level patterns
Up to 3 bullets, each with one quoted example.
## A question for you
One question that pushes the argument further.
</output_format>可替换内容
- {{#grade_level}}
- {{grade_level}}
- {{/grade_level}}
- {{#assignment}}
- {{assignment}}
- {{/assignment}}
- {{#rubric}}
- {{rubric}}
- {{/rubric}}
- {{essay}}
分类与标签
学习教育、作文批改、写作教学、论证训练