法律说法核验与条文对照
帮你梳理公共法律说法与所给条文的对应关系,输出核验表并提示解释分歧及待确认事项。
完整提示词
<context>
Viral claims about laws usually fail in predictable ways. A bill is described as if it were already law. A proposal by one member is presented as government policy. A narrow exception is read as a general ban, or a general rule is read as a new power that already existed. Defined terms ("vehicle", "public place", "child") mean what the definitions section says, not what they mean in everyday speech. Penalties, start dates, sunset clauses and exemptions are often in a different section from the headline provision. How courts or agencies will apply a provision is a separate question from what its words say, and it is where honest people disagree.
</context>
<task>
Check this claim against the legal text.
Claim:
<claim>
{{claim}}
</claim>
Jurisdiction and status: {{jurisdiction_and_status}}
Legal text:
<legal_text>
{{legal_text}}
</legal_text>
1. Break the claim into its parts: who it applies to, what it requires, forbids or allows, from when, the penalty, and the status ("is law", "will", "could").
2. For each part, find the provision that speaks to it and quote it with its section number. Read the definitions, exemptions, commencement and penalty sections before concluding.
3. Mark each part: Supported by the text, Not in the text, Contradicted by the text, or Depends on interpretation or later rules (for example powers to make regulations).
4. State whether the status claimed matches the status given ({{jurisdiction_and_status}}).
5. Write an accurate plain-language summary of what the text does, at the same length as the claim.
</task>
<constraints>
{{> guardrails/professional-limits}}
- Work only from the text supplied. Do not quote, number or summarise provisions that are not in it, and say when the claim depends on a part of the law that was not pasted.
- Do not predict how a court or agency will rule. Where the wording is open, describe the competing readings neutrally.
- Do not tell the reader what they personally must do to comply; this is a check of a public claim, not advice on their situation.
- Keep the jurisdiction fixed. If the claim mixes up countries or levels of government, say so.
</constraints>
<output_format>
## Verdict
One rating in bold (Accurate, Partly accurate, Misleading, Inaccurate, Cannot tell from this text), then two sentences.
## What the text says
Table: claim part | provision (section) | quoted words | mark.
## Where the claim goes wrong
Bullets naming each distortion: status, scope, definitions, exemptions, dates or penalties.
## Open questions
What depends on interpretation, missing sections or later regulations, and where the official answer would be found.
## Accurate summary
A plain-language replacement for the claim.
</output_format>可替换内容
- {{claim}}
- {{jurisdiction_and_status}}
- {{legal_text}}
- {{> guardrails/professional-limits}}
分类与标签
思维提升、法律事实核查、条文对照、公共说法辨析、证据核验