返回提示词目录第 1488 页

审查教育项目实施与成效

评估教育干预是否按设计落实,审视研究证据与本地适配度,并制定实施监测和成效评估方案。

完整提示词

Main objective:

> Perform a rigorous Implementation Fidelity Audit that connects education evidence quality, local context, implementation and measurable change in practice or learning.

## 1. QUESTION & CONTEXT

Define the problem, population, setting, target practice/outcome, available local data, decision stakes and intended use of the evidence.

## 2. SPECIALIZED WORKFLOW

- define core components and allowable adaptations
- measure whether delivery matched design
- capture dose/reach/quality
- identify drift
- link fidelity to outcomes cautiously
- distinguish intervention failure from implementation failure

## 3. RESEARCH QUALITY GATE

Check:
- claim-design match
- sampling and representativeness
- measurement validity
- confounding / selection bias
- attrition / missing data
- analysis appropriateness
- practical significance
- transparency / reproducibility
- applicability to the target educational setting

## 4. EVIDENCE TO PRACTICE

For each recommendation:
```text
Evidence:
Core mechanism:
Required conditions:
Local fit:
Adaptation allowed:
Implementation risk:
Measure of practice:
Measure of learner outcome:
Review point:
```

## 5. IMPLEMENTATION MODEL

Use phases:
1. Explore problem and evidence.
2. Prepare people, resources and measures.
3. Deliver with support.
4. Monitor implementation and outcomes.
5. Adapt where needed while preserving core mechanism.
6. Decide sustain / scale / modify / stop.

## 6. REQUIRED MATRICES

### Evidence Appraisal Matrix
| Source | Design | Claim supported | Bias | Context match | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|

### Implementation Matrix
| Component | Owner | Training/resource | Fidelity indicator | Adaptation | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|

### Outcome Matrix
| Outcome | Baseline | Measure | Timing | Result | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|

## 7. ANTI-OVERCLAIM RULES

Do not:
- infer causality from weak designs
- generalize one classroom result to all contexts
- treat statistical significance as educational importance
- ignore implementation failure
- claim success from satisfaction data alone
- cherry-pick positive outcomes
- omit null or adverse findings

## 8. REQUIRED OUTPUT

1. Problem and question.
2. Evidence summary.
3. Critical appraisal.
4. Local-context fit.
5. Implementation plan.
6. Required matrices.
7. Outcome/evaluation plan.
8. Sustain/scale/modify/stop decision criteria.

End with **Education Evidence Integrity Check** confirming that claims match the research design and that recommendations include implementation and evaluation requirements.

This supports education research and professional learning and does not replace required ethical, institutional or research procedures.

分类与标签

学习教育、教育项目评估、实施忠实度、研究证据、成效监测

前往 AI 图片创作