返回提示词目录第 1446 页

学徒制与大学学位路线对比

围绕学生个人情况,对比学徒制与大学学位的学习方式、费用、职业通道和后续选择。

完整提示词

<context>
A school leaver, often with a parent, is choosing between a specific apprenticeship and a specific degree. Country: {{country}}. Comparisons go wrong when they argue about routes in general ("degrees are worth more") instead of these two options, compare fees with wages without the full picture (loan repayment terms, living costs, wage rises, what happens after the end date), forget that some careers require a degree or a regulated qualification, and ignore how the student actually learns and what life they want at 18-21. The decision belongs to the student; the job is to make the trade-offs visible and the facts checkable.
</context>

<task>
<options>
{{options}}
</options>

<student_profile>
{{student_profile}}
</student_profile>

1. Summarise each route: what the student does day to day, length, qualification and level at the end, and where it typically leads.
2. Compare side by side: entry requirements and competition, day-to-day learning (work plus off-the-job training vs lectures and independent study), workload and independence, qualification gained, support, location and lifestyle, and drop-out or "what if it does not work out" options (switching, deferring, topping up to a degree later).
3. Money over five years: for each route, fees and how they are paid, loans and how repayment works where the student lives, living costs, wages or income while learning, and expected position at the end. Use only figures supplied; put [X] for unknowns and say where to find them. Do not total things that are uncertain.
4. Doors: careers each route opens, careers that need a degree or a regulated qualification, and how easy it is to switch later.
5. Fit: match each route against the student's profile point by point.
6. List the facts to verify and where (the employer, the university course page, the national apprenticeship or student-finance service, a careers adviser).
7. Bottom line: say which route fits better on what the student said, and the two or three questions that would change the answer. The choice stays with the student.
</task>

<constraints>
{{> guardrails/professional-limits}}
- If the country is not stated, ask for it; meanwhile describe the comparison without country-specific rules.
- If either option is only a name or a vague label ("an apprenticeship at a big firm", "uni"), ask for the wage, length, qualification and fees, keep the money table to the rows you can fill, and do not pad the answer with [X] cells.
- Never invent wages, fees, loan terms, salaries after qualifying or employment rates. Mark unknowns [X].
- Do not present either route as better in general, and do not rank universities or employers by reputation.
- Address the student directly and respect their preferences, including if they differ from a parent's.
- Suggest a qualified careers adviser for a personalised decision.
{{> output/uncertainty}}
</constraints>

<output_format>
## The two routes
Two short paragraphs, one per route.

## Side by side
Table: Factor | Apprenticeship | Degree.

## Money over five years
Table: Year | Apprenticeship (costs, income) | Degree (costs, income). Unknowns as [X]. Then two lines on loan repayment as it works where the student lives, or [verify].

## Doors opened and closed
Bullets per route.

## Fit with this student
Table: What the student said | Points to which route | Why.

## Facts to verify
Table: Fact | Route | Where to check.

## Bottom line
Under 120 words, ending with the questions that would change the answer.
</output_format>

可替换内容

  • {{country}}
  • {{options}}
  • {{student_profile}}
  • {{> guardrails/professional-limits}}
  • {{> output/uncertainty}}
  • [X]
  • [verify]

分类与标签

学习教育、升学选择、学徒制、大学申请、职业规划

前往 AI 图片创作