产品市场契合度证据审查
帮你梳理留存、付费与经营证据,形成契合度评估报告,列出关键假设、现金约束及验证实验。
完整提示词
I want a maximally deep, systematic, evidence-first and decision-oriented analysis. Main objective: > Assess product-market fit using behavioral and economic evidence rather than enthusiasm, survey vanity metrics or growth mainly purchased through incentives. This is not: - a generic startup checklist - automatic validation of the founder thesis - pitch-deck polishing - TAM treated as proof of demand - vanity metrics treated as proof of a healthy business - recommendation without economics, cash and execution constraints ## 1. CONTEXT DISCOVERY Before analysis establish: - company stage - product/service and target segment - problem and current alternatives - geography and market - pricing and monetization model - revenue stage and customer count - acquisition channels - retention/churn where available - gross and contribution margin where available - cash/runway where relevant - team, critical dependencies and decision context Calibrate expected evidence to the company's stage. Mark missing inputs NOT VERIFIED instead of guessing. ## 2. EVIDENCE MODEL A - direct customer, transaction, contract, cohort or cash evidence B - complete operating/financial evidence chain or multiple independent high-quality sources C - strong derived analysis with transparent formulas and assumptions D - credible inference requiring verification E - scenario, hypothesis or hardening recommendation Status: CONFIRMED SUPPORTED NOT VERIFIED CONTESTED NOT APPLICABLE SCENARIO ## 3. SOURCE AND METRIC DISCIPLINE Prefer direct customer/transaction data, contracts, bank/cash evidence, production analytics, cohort data, official sources and only then transparent estimates. For every financial metric show: ```text Metric: Definition: Numerator: Denominator: Period: Cohort/segment: Source: Formula: Result: Sensitivity: Known exclusions: ``` Explicitly distinguish revenue from cash, gross margin from contribution margin, averages from cohort data, blended CAC from channel CAC, and booked from collected revenue. ## 4. TARGET SEGMENT Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 5. CORE USE CASE Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 6. ACTIVATION Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 7. TIME TO VALUE Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 8. RETENTION Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 9. RETENTION CURVE Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 10. FREQUENCY Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 11. DEPTH OF USE Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 12. REPEAT PURCHASE Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 13. ORGANIC PULL Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 14. REFERRALS Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 15. WILLINGNESS TO PAY Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 16. PRICE SENSITIVITY Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 17. SUPPORT DEPENDENCY Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 18. CANCELLATION REASONS Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 19. CHURN REASONS Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 20. COHORT QUALITY Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 21. SEGMENT VARIANCE Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 22. CHANNEL VARIANCE Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 23. GROWTH QUALITY Analyze this area only when it changes the decision. For each material conclusion state the observed fact, assumption, mechanism, metric, evidence tier, time horizon, dependencies and what would falsify it. Separate current economics from economics at scale. ## 24. FALSE-POSITIVE PROTECTION Do not report a problem merely because the company is unprofitable, a process is manual at an early stage, founder-led sales matters, churn exists or runway misses an arbitrary internet benchmark. A finding requires a stage-appropriate expectation, a real mechanism of harm and a defensible consequence. Separate confirmed problems, normal stage tradeoffs, unverified assumptions, risk scenarios and optional hardening. ## 25. SEVERITY P0 - near-term failure path to insolvency, regulatory shutdown or loss of core operating capability P1 - core thesis/economics are materially wrong and can rapidly destroy value or runway P2 - significant issue changing growth quality, margin, cash or probability of success P3 - limited weakness or evidence gap P4 - hardening or monitoring ## 26. FINDING FORMAT ```text ID: Severity: Status: Evidence tier: Stage: Decision: Scope: Observed fact: Assumption: Metric/definition: Mechanism: Expected state: Observed state: Customer effect: Economic effect: Cash/runway effect: Scale effect: Dependencies: Evidence: Alternative explanation: What would falsify this finding: Remediation or experiment: Owner: Verification: Decision trigger: ``` ## 27. REQUIRED MATRICES ### Assumption Matrix | Assumption | Evidence | Criticality | Uncertainty | Cheapest falsification test | |---|---|---|---|---| ### Economics Matrix | Segment/channel | Revenue unit | Contribution margin | CAC | Retention/payback | Cash impact | |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| ### Dependency Matrix | Outcome | Dependency | Failure signal | Lead time | Mitigation | |---|---|---|---|---| ### Stage Evidence Matrix | Claim | Current evidence | Evidence tier | Next evidence milestone | Decision changed if false | |---|---|---|---|---| ## 28. FAILURE CHAINS Model at least 5 failure chains in this form: ```text condition ↓ trigger ↓ intermediate failure ↓ customer/economic/cash effect ↓ strategic consequence ``` Always test combined shocks: weaker retention + higher CAC, slower collections + hiring plan, partner/platform failure + weak runway. ## 29. EXPERIMENT DESIGN For every unverified critical assumption propose the smallest test capable of changing the decision. ```text Assumption: Why it matters: Test: Population: Success threshold: Failure threshold: Maximum cost: Maximum duration: Bias risks: Decision if passed: Decision if failed: ``` ## 30. ADVERSARIAL SECOND PASS - seek contrary customer evidence - inspect newest cohorts - test economics without the best channel - remove founder heroics from the operating model - test higher CAC and weaker retention - test slower collections and delayed financing - test partner/platform failure - check whether growth merely delays failure ## 31. FINAL QUALITY GATE Confirm: stage and decision context, customer evidence, willingness to pay, revenue vs cash, gross vs contribution margin, cohort quality, unit-economics definitions, runway timing, scale assumptions, falsifiability, false-positive protection, combined downside and decision triggers. ## 32. OUTPUT `PRODUCT_MARKET_FIT_EVIDENCE_AUDIT.md` The report begins with Executive summary, Decision context, Top 5 critical assumptions, Top confirmed risks, Top evidence gaps, Most important experiment, Economics snapshot, Cash/runway implication, Findings, Matrices, Failure chains and Decision triggers. # FINAL RULE Separate what we know, what we only believe, what it costs to learn, what economics and cash allow, and which evidence changes the decision.
分类与标签
商业营销、产品市场契合、创业验证、留存分析、商业模式、实验设计