电子与自动化合同风险审查
帮你梳理电子签约与自动履约的证据、责任及纠错机制,形成待法律专业确认的修订清单。
完整提示词
Main objective: > Audit contracts formed or performed through electronic communications, automated systems, AI or machine-to-machine processes, focusing on attribution, intent, authentication, timing, records, error handling and human oversight. This prompt is jurisdiction-adaptive and evidence-first. Do not assume a clause is enforceable, invalid, market-standard or legally required without checking the governing law and transaction context. ## 1. CONTRACT INTAKE Establish: - contract type and commercial objective - parties, legal capacities and bargaining roles - governing law, forum and dispute mechanism - signing / effective date and term - consideration, price and payment structure - deliverables, milestones, acceptance and service levels - regulated activities or industry-specific constraints - external policies, schedules, exhibits and incorporated documents - negotiation posture and non-negotiable business points ## 2. SPECIALIZED WORKFLOW - identify which acts are performed by humans, automated systems or AI-enabled systems - map offer, acceptance, attribution, dispatch, receipt and contract-formation events - test whether electronic records satisfy applicable writing, signature, original or retention requirements - analyze automated errors, input mistakes, anomalous outputs and correction mechanisms - identify who bears risk for system configuration, third-party tools and machine-generated actions - verify auditability, logs, evidence preservation, override and escalation controls ## 3. CLAUSE MECHANICS For every material clause identify: ```text Clause: Purpose: Trigger: Actor: Obligation / right: Standard: Deadline: Dependency: Exception: Discretion: Evidence of performance: Breach consequence: Remedy: Survival: Interaction with other clauses: Governing-law sensitivity: Operational owner: ``` ## 4. RISK MODEL Rate separately: - legal enforceability risk - commercial exposure - financial exposure - operational burden - ambiguity / interpretation risk - compliance risk - dispute likelihood - remediation difficulty Use P0-P4: P0 - structural defect capable of invalidating the deal, authority, legality or core enforceability P1 - material clause risk that can materially change liability, economics, termination or ownership P2 - significant but manageable exposure requiring negotiation or controls P3 - drafting weakness, ambiguity or dependency that should be cleaned up P4 - optimization, market-positioning or clarity improvement ## 5. DRAFTING QUALITY TESTS Test for: - undefined or inconsistently used terms - circular definitions - conflicting clauses - impossible or unverifiable obligations - subjective standards without objective anchors - silent assumptions - missing triggers, deadlines or consequences - unbounded discretion - obligations with no remedy - remedies with no breach trigger - survival inconsistencies - precedence conflicts between body, schedules and policies - language that does not match the intended business outcome ## 6. GOVERNING-LAW GATE For any jurisdiction-sensitive issue: 1. identify the proposition 2. locate current primary authority or authoritative official guidance 3. verify date, jurisdiction and applicability 4. distinguish mandatory law from default rules 5. separate enforceability risk from drafting preference 6. state uncertainty explicitly Never invent mandatory clauses, statutory wording, cases or market standards. ## 7. SPECIALIZED MATRICES - **Automation Responsibility Matrix**: include clause reference, issue, risk owner, legal/commercial impact, evidence, proposed fix and fallback. - **Formation Event Timeline**: include clause reference, issue, risk owner, legal/commercial impact, evidence, proposed fix and fallback. - **Electronic Evidence Register**: include clause reference, issue, risk owner, legal/commercial impact, evidence, proposed fix and fallback. - **Error and Override Control Matrix**: include clause reference, issue, risk owner, legal/commercial impact, evidence, proposed fix and fallback. ## 8. NEGOTIATION OUTPUT For each material issue provide: ```text Issue: Why it matters: Current wording effect: Preferred position: Proposed redline: Fallback position: Walk-away threshold: Tradeable concession: Counterparty likely objection: Response: Residual risk if accepted: ``` ## 9. REQUIRED OUTPUT Return: 1. Executive contract risk summary. 2. Assumptions and jurisdiction gate. 3. Contract architecture map. 4. Material findings ranked P0-P4. 5. Specialized matrices. 6. Redline recommendations. 7. Negotiation priorities and fallback positions. 8. Missing information / schedules / approvals. 9. Operational implementation checklist. 10. Final "deal still works?" consistency review. End with **Contract Integrity Check** confirming that every material obligation has a clear actor, trigger, standard, deadline, dependency and consequence, and that every jurisdiction-specific claim is verified or explicitly unresolved. This supports contract review and drafting preparation. It does not replace qualified legal advice in the relevant jurisdiction.
分类与标签
办公效率、电子签约、自动履约、合同审查、谈判准备