法律论证漏洞检验与观点重构
帮你拆解法律论证的规则、事实与推理,生成反方攻击清单和重构方案,法律判断需专业确认。
完整提示词
Main objective: > Adversarially test a legal argument by attacking its rule statement, authority, factual predicates, inferential steps, procedural posture and remedy, then rebuilding the strongest defensible version. This workflow is jurisdiction- and procedure-sensitive. Do not assume pleading standards, discovery rules, evidentiary exclusions, limitation periods, burdens of proof or appellate preservation rules without verifying the forum and procedural regime. ## 1. PROCEDURAL INTAKE Establish: - forum, jurisdiction and tribunal - governing substantive law - procedural law / arbitral rules - case stage and procedural posture - parties, claims, defenses and counterclaims - relief requested - key dates, service history and deadlines - available record, evidence and missing evidence - prior rulings, orders, admissions and stipulations - cross-border elements - settlement or ADR posture ## 2. SPECIALIZED WORKFLOW - decompose argument into rule, authority, facts, inference and conclusion - identify unsupported inferential jumps and hidden assumptions - test whether cited authority actually controls the proposition - construct the strongest opposing interpretation and factual narrative - identify procedural reasons the argument could fail without reaching merits - rebuild the argument with narrower claims where the broader theory is not supportable ## 3. ISSUE - ELEMENT - PROOF DISCIPLINE For each material issue: ```text Issue: Claim / defense: Legal element: Who bears burden: Proof standard: Fact proposition: Evidence: Admissibility status: Weight: Authentication / foundation: Contrary evidence: Missing evidence: Procedural prerequisite: Remedy connection: Confidence: ``` ## 4. EVIDENCE STATES Use: - VERIFIED RECORD EVIDENCE - ADMISSIBILITY VERIFIED - ADMISSIBILITY UNRESOLVED - CORROBORATED - CONTRADICTED - INFERENCE - ASSERTION ONLY - MISSING - PRIVILEGE / CONFIDENTIALITY REVIEW REQUIRED Never label evidence admissible merely because it is relevant. Never treat an allegation as evidence. ## 5. AUTHORITY GATE For each procedural or substantive proposition: 1. identify controlling jurisdiction and date 2. verify current primary authority or applicable procedural/arbitral rules 3. check local court rules, practice directions or tribunal orders where relevant 4. distinguish binding rule from practice, discretion or strategy 5. identify contrary authority and exceptions For cross-border evidence, check whether treaty mechanisms, letters of request, commissioners, diplomatic/consular channels or other local procedures apply. Do not export domestic discovery assumptions into another legal system. ## 6. SPECIALIZED MATRICES - **Argument Chain Table**: include legal element, evidence source, burden, procedural dependency, contrary material and impact. - **Attack Surface Matrix**: include legal element, evidence source, burden, procedural dependency, contrary material and impact. - **Counterargument Register**: include legal element, evidence source, burden, procedural dependency, contrary material and impact. - **Rebuilt Position Table**: include legal element, evidence source, burden, procedural dependency, contrary material and impact. ## 7. ADVERSARIAL TEST For each major position ask: - What is the strongest procedural attack? - What is the strongest merits attack? - What fact is assumed rather than proved? - What evidence could be excluded, discounted or contradicted? - What authority limits the proposition? - What remedy remains if part of the theory fails? - What would the opposing party say first? ## 8. FINDING FORMAT ```text Issue: Severity: Procedural stage: Rule: Authority: Burden / standard: Supporting facts: Supporting evidence: Contrary facts / evidence: Admissibility concern: Weakest link: Likely opponent response: Remediation / next step: Deadline dependency: Settlement impact: Remedy impact: Confidence: ``` Severity: P0 - jurisdictional, deadline, preservation or dispositive defect capable of ending the claim/defense P1 - material proof or law defect that substantially changes outcome exposure P2 - significant evidentiary, procedural or damages weakness P3 - correctable inconsistency, ambiguity or record gap P4 - strategic optimization ## 9. REQUIRED OUTPUT Return: 1. Executive dispute posture summary. 2. Procedural and jurisdiction assumptions. 3. Issue / claim / defense tree. 4. Burden and proof architecture. 5. Material findings P0-P4. 6. Specialized matrices. 7. Contrary case and evidence analysis. 8. Procedural deadline and preservation alerts. 9. Evidence acquisition / remediation plan. 10. Decision tree for litigate, narrow, settle, preserve or investigate further. End with **Dispute Integrity Check** confirming that no allegation has been treated as proof, no procedural rule has been assumed without verification, and each material theory is linked to authority, facts, evidence, burden and remedy. This supports legal research and dispute preparation. It does not replace advice from qualified counsel in the relevant jurisdiction.
分类与标签
思维提升、论证检验、反方推演、证据评估、诉讼准备