财务报表异常与质量核查
逐项核对三大报表及附注,梳理收入、现金流和会计处理中的异常信号,并标明证据等级、重要性与待核实事项。
完整提示词
I want a forensic analysis of the financial statements with a focus on anomalies, aggressive accounting, earnings quality, classifications, timing and the mutual consistency of the Income Statement, Balance Sheet and Cash Flow Statement. Main objective: > Find the places where reported financial performance may not represent the economic reality of the business, without accusing anyone of fraud without evidence. This is not: - a fraud accusation generator - automatically declaring an accounting estimate to be manipulation - only a ratio analysis - only a Benford test - a replacement for a formal audit ## 1. SOURCE QUALITY Establish: - audited? - auditor opinion - period - accounting framework - restatements - notes available ## 2. THREE-STATEMENT RECONCILIATION Check the links between: - profit - retained earnings - cash - debt - working capital ## 3. REVENUE QUALITY Look for: - unusual period-end spike - receivable growth > revenue - contract assets - deferred revenue - returns - bill-and-hold indicators where evidence exists ## 4. RECEIVABLES ## 5. DSO ## 6. ALLOWANCE ## 7. BAD DEBT ## 8. INVENTORY ## 9. INVENTORY GROWTH ## 10. OBSOLESCENCE RESERVE ## 11. GROSS MARGIN Sudden unexplained movements. ## 12. COGS CLASSIFICATION ## 13. CAPITALIZATION Costs that might otherwise be expensed. ## 14. DEVELOPMENT COST ## 15. SOFTWARE COST ## 16. CAPITALIZED INTEREST ## 17. DEPRECIATION POLICY ## 18. USEFUL LIFE ## 19. RESIDUAL VALUE ## 20. IMPAIRMENT ## 21. GOODWILL ## 22. INTANGIBLES ## 23. ACQUISITION ACCOUNTING ## 24. PROVISION ## 25. RESERVE RELEASE ## 26. RESTRUCTURING ## 27. "NON-RECURRING" ## 28. STOCK-BASED COMPENSATION ## 29. RELATED PARTY ## 30. OFF-BALANCE-SHEET ## 31. LEASE ## 32. DEBT CLASSIFICATION ## 33. CURRENT/NON-CURRENT ## 34. COVENANT ## 35. CONTINGENCY ## 36. TAX ## 37. DEFERRED TAX ## 38. CASH TAX VS ACCOUNTING TAX ## 39. OPERATING CASH FLOW ## 40. CLASSIFICATION Interest/dividends depending on the accounting framework. ## 41. FREE CASH FLOW ## 42. PROFIT VS CFO ## 43. ACCRUALS ## 44. TOTAL ACCRUAL RATIO Use carefully. ## 45. CASH CONVERSION ## 46. PERIOD-END WINDOW DRESSING Only report with evidence. ## 47. SUPPLIER PAYMENT TIMING ## 48. FACTORING ## 49. RECEIVABLE SALE ## 50. SUPPLY CHAIN FINANCE ## 51. DEBT-LIKE ITEMS ## 52. CASH-LIKE ITEMS ## 53. RECLASSIFICATION ## 54. RESTATEMENT ## 55. ACCOUNTING POLICY CHANGE ## 56. ESTIMATE CHANGE ## 57. AUDITOR CHANGE Signal, not proof. ## 58. MANAGEMENT KPI Reconcile to statutory data. ## 59. ADJUSTED EBITDA ## 60. NON-GAAP ## 61. RECONCILIATION ## 62. SEGMENT REPORTING ## 63. GEOGRAPHIC REPORTING ## 64. CONCENTRATION ## 65. FOOTNOTES High-value. ## 66. COMMITMENTS ## 67. GUARANTEES ## 68. LEGAL ## 69. PENSION ## 70. MINORITY INTEREST ## 71. DILUTION ## 72. SHARE COUNT ## 73. EPS ## 74. CASH RESTRICTION ## 75. SUBSIDIARY CASH ## 76. CURRENCY TRANSLATION ## 77. HYPERINFLATION If relevant. ## 78. ANOMALY TREND ## 79. PEER COMPARISON Only comparable accounting/business models. ## 80. FORENSIC SIGNALS A signal is not fraud proof. ## 81. FRAUD LANGUAGE RULE Never write: ```text "management manipulated earnings" ``` unless there is direct reliable evidence. Prefer: ```text "This pattern warrants further verification because..." ``` ## 82. EVIDENCE TIERS ```text A - audited note/reconciliation/direct ledger evidence B - deterministic statement inconsistency C - strong multi-period accounting anomaly D - forensic signal requiring verification E - analytical question ``` Materiality is the severity scale of this analysis: **HIGH** changes the overall conclusion, a decision or the liquidity outlook; **MEDIUM** changes a key metric or trend but not the conclusion; **LOW** has a limited effect and is noted for completeness. Judge it against an explicit base (profit, operating cash flow, total assets or equity) and state that base. A finding is CONFIRMED only with evidence tier A or B; tier C is LIKELY; tier D stays NOT VERIFIED, and tier E is an open analytical question, not a finding. A pattern with a legitimate, documented explanation is a false positive: mark it EXPLAINED instead of reporting it as an anomaly. ## 83. STATUS ```text CONFIRMED LIKELY NOT VERIFIED EXPLAINED NOT APPLICABLE ``` ## 84. FINDING FORMAT ```text ID: Materiality: Status: Evidence tier: Statement/account: Period: Observed pattern: Expected relationship: Difference: Cash impact: Possible explanations: Evidence: Additional evidence required: Conclusion: ``` ## 85. ANOMALY MATRIX | Signal | Current | Prior | Cash effect | Explanation | |---|---|---|---|---| ## 86. SECOND PASS Revisit: - revenue vs receivables - profit vs cash - inventory vs sales - capitalization - reserve release - debt classification - adjusted metrics - related parties - notes - restatements ## 87. FINAL QUALITY GATE Confirm: - three statements reconcile - footnotes reviewed - anomalies distinguished from proof - materiality considered - alternative explanations considered - accounting framework considered ## 88. OUTPUT `FINANCIAL_STATEMENT_FORENSIC_ANALYSIS.md` # FINAL RULE A forensic analysis should find: ```text what does not fit + why it is material + which legitimate explanations exist + which evidence is needed to establish what actually happened ```
分类与标签
财务理财、财务报表审阅、盈利质量分析、会计异常核查