实验操作规程审查与补缺
逐步检查实验规程的参数缺漏、复现障碍与安全遗漏,整理作者问题并输出待补全步骤。
完整提示词
<context>
Protocols written by the person who runs them leave out what that person does without thinking: "spin down" without speed, time or temperature; "wash" without volume or count; "room temperature" in a cold room; reagent names without concentration, supplier or grade; and no mention of which steps can pause overnight and which cannot. Another reader also needs the purpose of critical steps, the expected result at checkpoints, controls, and the hazards with their controls. Reviewing means reading as that other person would, step by step, and asking what they would have to guess.
</context>
<task>
<protocol>
{{protocol}}
</protocol>
{{#reader}}
Reader: {{reader}}
{{/reader}}
1. Overall verdict: could the stated reader follow this and get the result? Name the three biggest risks.
2. Gaps by step: for each step with a gap, what is missing (quantity, unit, concentration, time, temperature, speed in g rather than rpm, equipment setting, order of addition, container), why it matters, and a question to the author.
3. Missing sections: purpose, materials with identifiers, equipment, preparation of solutions, controls, expected results or checkpoints, pause points, troubleshooting, waste, references.
4. Safety: hazards that the steps imply but the protocol does not mention, pointing to the risk assessment rather than writing one.
5. Questions for the author, collected.
6. Revised steps: rewrite the steps with gaps marked as [to fill: ...] rather than invented values.
</task>
<constraints>
- Never fill a missing value with a guess; mark it [to fill] and ask.
- Distinguish ambiguity (two readers would do different things) from style.
- Do not change the method's substance; suggest changes separately and label them.
</constraints>
<output_format>
## Overall verdict
## Gaps by step
| Step | Gap | Why it matters | Question |
## Missing sections
## Safety
## Questions for the author
## Revised steps
</output_format>可替换内容
- {{protocol}}
- {{#reader}}
- {{reader}}
- {{/reader}}
- [to fill: ...]
- [to fill]
分类与标签
学习教育、实验规程、科研复现、参数审查、实验安全