返回提示词目录第 1300 页

质性研究论文审稿评估

依据论文所用方法评估研究一致性、分析透明度与报告规范,给出修改清单及审稿结论。

完整提示词

<context>
Qualitative manuscripts are often reviewed badly by people trained in quantitative work: they ask for larger samples, statistical generalisability, inter-rater reliability scores or "saturation" regardless of the approach, which can be wrong for the methodology. Reflexive thematic analysis, for example, does not aim for coder agreement and treats saturation as a poor fit; IPA uses small homogeneous samples on purpose; grounded theory expects theoretical sampling and constant comparison. The useful questions are about coherence (do the research question, philosophical stance, sampling, data collection and analysis fit together?), transparency (can a reader see how themes were built?), reflexivity (how the researchers' position shaped the work), whether themes are analytic claims rather than topic summaries, whether quotations support the claims and come from across participants, and whether the authors claim transferability honestly. Common real flaws are themes that are just the interview questions, a method named but not followed, and conclusions that count heads as if the sample were representative.
</context>

<task>
Review this qualitative manuscript{{#methodology}}, which uses {{methodology}}{{/methodology}}.
<manuscript>
{{manuscript}}
</manuscript>

1. Summarise the question, the approach, the participants and setting, and the main themes or findings in your own words.
2. Judge methodological coherence: whether the question, stated paradigm, sampling strategy, data collection and analysis method belong together, and whether the method named is the method actually described.
3. Check sampling and data: recruitment, who is missing, the rationale for sample size given the approach, and the depth of the data (interview length, field time).
4. Check analysis transparency: how codes became themes, who analysed, how disagreement or alternative readings were handled, and whether an audit trail or codebook is described.
5. Check findings: whether each theme is an interpretive claim rather than a topic label or a mirror of the interview guide, whether quotations support the claim, whether quotes are spread across participants, and whether disconfirming cases are discussed.
6. Check reflexivity, ethics (consent, identifiability of quotes in small communities) and the honesty of claims about transferability.
7. Name the reporting guideline that applies (COREQ for interviews and focus groups, SRQR more broadly) and note important missing items.
8. Recommend accept, minor revision, major revision or reject, following from the major issues.
</task>

<constraints>
- Judge the work against its own stated methodology. Do not request statistical generalisability, larger samples, inter-rater reliability or saturation unless the chosen approach calls for them; if you think the approach itself is wrong for the question, argue that directly.
- Every issue names a location and a concrete request.
- Do not invent quotations, participant details or method steps not in the text.
- If the methodology is unnamed or mixed, say what you inferred and review against that.
- Start with one line reminding the reviewer that the manuscript is confidential and to check the venue's AI-use policy.
</constraints>

<output_format>
One reminder line, then:
## Summary
One paragraph.
## Methodological coherence
Three to six sentences.
## Major issues
Numbered: location, problem, why it matters, what would resolve it.
## Minor issues
Numbered, one or two lines each.
## Reporting
The guideline, and missing items.
## Recommendation
The recommendation and the deciding reasons.
</output_format>

可替换内容

  • {{#methodology}}
  • {{methodology}}
  • {{/methodology}}
  • {{manuscript}}

分类与标签

学习教育、质性研究、论文审稿、研究方法、学术规范

前往 AI 图片创作