审查企业财务内部控制
帮你梳理财务控制的设计与执行证据,形成控制矩阵、缺陷分级及整改复测清单。
完整提示词
I want a deep audit of the internal financial controls framework focused on material reporting, authorization, segregation of duties, reconciliations, master data and manual adjustments. Main objective: > Determine whether preventive and detective controls exist that realistically prevent, or detect in time, material error, unauthorized transactions and reporting misstatement. This is not: - automatically applying SOX to every company - compliance certification - "more approvals = better control" - only a policy review ## 1. CONTROL OBJECTIVE For each control: ```text Risk: Control objective: Control: Owner: Frequency: Evidence: Preventive/detective: Manual/automated: ``` ## 2. ENTITY-LEVEL CONTROLS ## 3. FINANCIAL CLOSE ## 4. JOURNAL ENTRY ## 5. RECONCILIATION ## 6. REVENUE ## 7. EXPENSE ## 8. AR ## 9. AP ## 10. CASH ## 11. PAYROLL ## 12. INVENTORY ## 13. FIXED ASSET ## 14. TAX ## 15. CONSOLIDATION ## 16. MASTER DATA ## 17. VENDOR MASTER ## 18. CUSTOMER MASTER ## 19. BANK DETAILS ## 20. CHART OF ACCOUNTS ## 21. ACCESS ## 22. PRIVILEGED USER ## 23. SEGREGATION OF DUTIES ## 24. CONFLICTING ROLES ## 25. COMPENSATING CONTROL ## 26. APPROVAL ## 27. THRESHOLD ## 28. SPLIT TRANSACTION ## 29. AUTOMATED CONTROL ## 30. SYSTEM CONFIGURATION ## 31. IT DEPENDENCE ## 32. REPORT USED IN CONTROL IUC/IPE reliability. ## 33. COMPLETENESS ## 34. ACCURACY ## 35. REVIEW CONTROL ## 36. PRECISION Does review operate at level capable of detecting material error? ## 37. EVIDENCE ## 38. RETENTION ## 39. EXCEPTION ## 40. FOLLOW-UP ## 41. CONTROL FAILURE ## 42. REMEDIATION ## 43. REPEAT DEFICIENCY ## 44. DESIGN EFFECTIVENESS ## 45. OPERATING EFFECTIVENESS Distinct. ## 46. CONTROL FREQUENCY ## 47. POPULATION ## 48. SAMPLE If performing test. ## 49. MATERIALITY ## 50. RISK ## 51. FALSE POSITIVE RULES No segregation is not automatically a failure in tiny organization if effective compensating control exists. Manual control is not inherently weak. ## 52. EVIDENCE TIERS ```text A - control performance evidence and reperformance B - complete design/configuration proof C - strong control evidence D - suspected weakness E - maturity hardening ``` A deficiency is CONFIRMED (status DEFICIENT) only with evidence tier A or B; tier C is a LIKELY deficiency; tier D stays NOT VERIFIED; tier E is HARDENING. The status EFFECTIVE requires evidence that the control actually operated, not just evidence of its design. ## 53. STATUS ```text EFFECTIVE DEFICIENT NOT VERIFIED COMPENSATED NOT APPLICABLE HARDENING ``` ## 54. SEVERITY P0: - systemic absence/failure allowing catastrophic material reporting corruption P1: - material control deficiency with realistic misstatement/fraud exposure P2: - significant control weakness P3: - limited deficiency P4: - hardening ## 55. FINDING FORMAT ```text ID: Severity: Status: Evidence tier: Risk: Control objective: Control: Owner: Frequency: Expected operation: Observed operation: Deficiency: Potential misstatement: Evidence: Compensating control: Remediation: Retest: ``` ## 56. CONTROL MATRIX | Risk | Control | Type | Owner | Evidence | Status | |---|---|---|---|---|---| ## 57. SECOND PASS Review: - admin users - manual journals - bank changes - close - reconciliations - spreadsheet controls - reports used in controls - repeat deficiencies - compensating controls ## 58. FINAL QUALITY GATE Confirm: - risks - objectives - design - operation - evidence - access - SOD - reconciliations - journals - master data - reporting - remediation ## 59. OUTPUT `INTERNAL_FINANCIAL_CONTROLS_AUDIT.md` # FINAL RULE A control is not good because it exists in a policy document. You must prove: ```text a relevant risk + a precise control + actual performance + evidence + the ability to prevent or detect a material problem ```
分类与标签
财务理财、财务内控、审计证据、职责分离、整改复测