整合性文献综述研究方案规划
判断综述类型是否适合课题,规划检索、质量评价与资料综合方法,并列出待定事项和时间表。
完整提示词
<context>
The integrative review, widely used in nursing and health professions research, combines experimental and non-experimental studies (and sometimes theoretical literature) to give a fuller picture of a phenomenon than one design can. The most cited method is Whittemore and Knafl's (2005) five stages: problem identification, literature search, data evaluation, data analysis, and presentation. Its strength is breadth; its weakness is rigour, because combining diverse designs invites bias. The commonest faults are a vague purpose that cannot guide selection, a search that is not reproducible, appraisal done and then ignored, and an "analysis" that is a study-by-study summary. Data analysis should follow the method's steps: data reduction (classifying and extracting into a common format), data display (matrices or charts), data comparison (finding patterns and themes), and conclusion drawing and verification (checking conclusions against the primary sources). It also needs a clear reason it is not a scoping review (which maps without appraising to answer a question) or a mixed-methods systematic review (which has its own formal methods, for example JBI's).
</context>
<task>
Plan an integrative review on:
<topic>
{{topic}}
</topic>
{{#purpose}}Purpose and rules: {{purpose}}{{/purpose}}
{{#team}}Team and time: {{team}}{{/team}}
1. Test whether an integrative review is the right choice against a systematic review, a mixed-methods systematic review and a scoping review, and say why. If another type fits better, say so and stop after a short explanation.
2. Problem identification: write the review purpose and one or two review questions, the variables or concepts of interest, and the inclusion and exclusion criteria (designs, populations, settings, dates, languages) with a reason for each.
3. Literature search: databases suited to the topic, a search structure by concept, supplementary methods (citation chasing, grey literature, hand searching), and how the search and selection will be recorded (for example a PRISMA-style flow diagram).
4. Data evaluation: how quality will be appraised across diverse designs (a design-specific tool for each design, or a tool for mixed designs such as the MMAT), who appraises, and how quality will be used in the analysis (sensitivity of conclusions to weaker studies, weighting in narrative) rather than only reported.
5. Data analysis: plan each step (data reduction into a matrix with named fields, data display, data comparison for patterns, themes and contradictions, and conclusion drawing and verification against the primary sources).
6. Presentation: how findings will be reported (a summary table of included studies, themes, a conceptual model if justified), limitations, implications, and reporting guidance to adapt, since no single reporting guideline exists for integrative reviews.
7. List open decisions and a realistic timeline for the team.
</task>
<constraints>
- Do not run searches or report results; this is a plan.
- Name appraisal tools and frameworks only as widely used options; tell the user to check their programme's or journal's expectations and the current versions.
- Every inclusion criterion and method choice gets a one-line reason.
- Flag where a second reviewer is needed for credibility (selection, appraisal, verification) and what to do if only one person is available (state it as a limitation and use checks such as supervisor sampling).
- If the topic is too broad for the time or team, propose a narrower purpose.
</constraints>
<output_format>
## Is an integrative review right
Short comparison and the decision.
## Problem and purpose
Purpose, questions, and a criteria table: criterion | include | exclude | reason.
## Literature search
Bullets and a search structure in a code block.
## Data evaluation
Bullets.
## Data analysis
Numbered steps with the extraction matrix fields.
## Presentation and reporting
Bullets.
## Open decisions
Bullets, then a timeline table.
</output_format>可替换内容
- {{topic}}
- {{#purpose}}
- {{purpose}}
- {{/purpose}}
- {{#team}}
- {{team}}
- {{/team}}
分类与标签
学习教育、整合性综述、文献检索规划、质量评价、研究时间表