返回提示词目录第 1292 页

比较自主投资与顾问服务方式

对比自主投资、智能投顾和人工顾问的费用、服务与适用情境,并用标注假设的示例展示成本差异。

完整提示词

<context>
There are three broad ways to invest: do it yourself on a platform or broker, use a robo-adviser that builds and rebalances a portfolio from a questionnaire, or pay a human adviser (ongoing, one-off, or a hybrid that pairs an app with occasional advice). The right route depends less on returns, which nobody can promise, and more on cost over decades, how much the person wants to decide themselves, how complex their situation is (pensions, tax, property, business, inheritance), and how they behave when markets fall. Fees compound just like returns, so a percentage that sounds small becomes a large amount of money over 20 years.

{{#amount_range}}Amount: {{amount_range}}{{/amount_range}}
{{#experience}}Experience: {{experience}}{{/experience}}
{{#preferences}}Preferences: {{preferences}}{{/preferences}}
</context>

<task>
1. If no details are given, ask for amount, experience and what matters most (up to three questions) and give the comparison on a labelled example meanwhile.
2. Compare the three routes (plus a hybrid if relevant) on: what you get, who chooses the investments, typical cost structure, minimums, support during a market fall, help with tax and pensions, and how much time it takes.
3. Cost in money: for the person's amount (or an example such as 20,000 plus 300 a month), compute illustrative yearly cost and the 20-year cost of each route under labelled assumptions - for example DIY with low-cost index funds about 0.2-0.5% all-in, robo-adviser about 0.5-1.0% all-in, ongoing human advice about 1.5-2.0% all-in including fund costs, and a one-off advice fee as a flat amount. Use the same hypothetical gross return (say 5% a year) for every route and show the difference in ending value. State that the ranges vary by country and provider and must be checked against real quotes.
4. Who each route tends to suit: describe situations, not this person's choice - for example DIY for people who want control and will not panic-sell; robo for people who want automation at low cost; human advice for complex situations, large or life-changing sums, or people who value behavioural coaching. Relate this to what they told you.
5. Questions that decide it: 6-8 questions the person can answer themselves (Will I rebalance? What did I do the last time markets fell 20%? Do I need tax or pension planning beyond picking funds?).
6. Before you sign up anywhere: check regulation and the official register, investor compensation or custody protection, all fees in money, what happens to assets if the firm fails, how to leave and the exit fees.
</task>

<constraints>
{{> guardrails/professional-limits}}
- Never name platforms, robo-advisers, brokers, advisers or funds, and never say which route this person should pick. Lay out the trade-offs and let them decide.
- All costs and returns are labelled illustrations. Show the compounding formula once.
- Do not promise that any route earns more; the only near-certain difference is cost.
- If the amount is small relative to likely advice fees, say plainly that ongoing advice may cost more than it is worth at that size and mention free or low-cost guidance services that may exist in their country.
{{> output/uncertainty}}
</constraints>

<output_format>
## The short answer
Three sentences on what decides it for someone in their position.

## The three routes compared
Table: | DIY | robo-adviser | human adviser | with rows for each dimension.

## Cost in money
Table: route | assumed all-in cost | cost in year 1 | ending value after 20 years | difference versus cheapest. Then the formula.

## Who each route tends to suit
Short paragraphs.

## Questions that decide it
Numbered.

## Before you sign up anywhere
Checklist.
</output_format>

可替换内容

  • {{#amount_range}}
  • {{amount_range}}
  • {{/amount_range}}
  • {{#experience}}
  • {{experience}}
  • {{/experience}}
  • {{#preferences}}
  • {{preferences}}
  • {{/preferences}}
  • {{> guardrails/professional-limits}}
  • {{> output/uncertainty}}

分类与标签

财务理财、投资方式比较、顾问服务、费用测算

前往 AI 图片创作