科研研究方案红队审查
围绕研究主张审查测量、抽样与分析方案,输出偏差地图、假设清单、改进优先级及推断边界。
完整提示词
Main objective: > Perform a rigorous Study Design Red-Team Review workflow connecting question, claim, design, measurement, sampling, analysis and inference limits. ## 1. RESEARCH CONTEXT Establish domain, research aim, unit of analysis, target population/system, time horizon, data availability, ethical constraints, resources, decision stakes and intended claim type. ## 2. SPECIALIZED WORKFLOW - attack identification, measurement, sampling, analysis and interpretation - construct strongest alternative explanation - identify hidden researcher degrees of freedom - test robustness requirements - surface assumptions that could reverse conclusion - produce redesign priorities ## 3. CLAIM-DESIGN GATE Every major claim must map to a design capable of supporting it. Distinguish: - description - association - prediction - intervention effect - causal effect - mechanism - generalization Do not let wording outrun identification. ## 4. PRE-SPECIFICATION Capture: ```text Primary question: Primary outcome / estimand: Key exposure/intervention: Comparator: Population: Sampling: Design: Primary analysis: Exclusions: Missing-data strategy: Sensitivity analyses: Confirmatory vs exploratory: Deviation log: ``` ## 5. BIAS & VALIDITY Audit selection bias, measurement error, confounding, attrition, missingness, researcher degrees of freedom, temporal ambiguity, multiplicity and external-validity limits. ## 6. REPORTING STANDARDS Use design-appropriate reporting guidance. For example, CONSORT 2025 applies to randomized trial reporting, STROBE to major observational designs, and PRISMA 2020 to systematic reviews. Reporting checklists improve transparency but are not themselves proof of methodological quality. ## 7. REQUIRED MATRICES ### Question-Design Matrix | Claim | Design | Required data | Main bias | Identifiable? | Limitation | |---|---|---|---|---|---| ### Variable Matrix | Construct | Operational measure | Role | Timing | Validity | Error risk | |---|---|---|---|---|---| ### Assumption Register | Assumption | Why needed | Evidence | Failure consequence | Test / sensitivity | |---|---|---|---|---| ## 8. REQUIRED OUTPUT 1. Research question and claim type. 2. Design choice and alternatives. 3. Variable / measurement plan. 4. Sampling plan. 5. Bias and validity map. 6. Analysis / preregistration outline. 7. Sensitivity requirements. 8. Inference boundaries. End with **Study Design Integrity Check** confirming that the proposed claim does not exceed what the design and data can support. This supports research planning and does not replace required ethics review, specialist methodological consultation or domain-specific standards.
分类与标签
学习教育、科研方法、研究方案审查、偏差与效度、推断边界